Satisfaction, problems and effects on political trust and legitimacy.
Period: July 2023 – December 2024
Funding source: Generalitat de Catalunya. Department of External Action and Open Government.
Program and call: DEMOC grants for research projects in the field of democratic quality
Reference number: EXI100/22/000007
Project coordinator: Rosa Borge (CNSC, IN3-UOC) – Principal Investigator.
Participants in the project: Rosa Borge Bravo (leader of the CNSC, IN3-UOC), Joan Balcells Padullés (GADE, UOC), Albert Padró-Solanet (GADE, UOC), Carol Galais González (UAB), Carola Castellà Josa (DIBA) , Raül Rodríguez Fernández (CNSC, IN3-UOC), Andreu Orte del Molino (DIBA), Laia Márquez Muñoz (CNSC, IN3-UOC), Joel Peiruza Parga (CNSC, IN3-UOC)
Description:
In recent years, the number of participatory budgets throughout Catalonia has multiplied. Simultaneously, there has been a trend towards the progressive digitization of these processes using platforms such as Decidim. The result is a rich but fragmented map of participatory budgets in Catalonia, featuring diverse approaches and varying methods for evaluating their impact and functioning.
The gap between the expectations associated with these processes and the final results can lead to attrition and adverse effects. Therefore, it is crucial to focus on how different actors involved evaluate and perceive the functioning of participatory budgets. This assessment is sought not only by administrations but also by citizens.
The aim is to establish common criteria and methodology for the public evaluation of participatory budgets. Additionally, the intention is for it to be useful for all local administrations, promoting comparability and continuous improvement.
General Objectives:
(1) Measure the level of satisfaction of citizens with participatory budgets carried out in Catalonia through the Decidim platform in the last two years.
(2) Propose a common methodology for all municipalities to capture this citizen satisfaction and its impact on their political attitudes, primarily on trust in local institutions and the legitimacy of municipal politics.
Operational objectives:
(1) Collection of information from all surveys and satisfaction questionnaires with the processes for comparative analysis and proposal of a common minimum questionnaire among municipalities.
(2) Update a database on participatory budget processes in Catalan municipalities, including variables on various phases of the process and compositional characteristics of the municipalities.
(3) Case study analysis in 4 different municipalities conducting participatory budgets between 2023 and 2024.
(4) Proposal of procedures and methods to evaluate participant satisfaction to capture the impact of the process on participant attitudes.
(5) Special emphasis on citizen evaluation of deliberative phases due to their relevance and impact on political attitudes.
(6) Analysis of the impact on political attitudes, primarily on trust and legitimacy of local political institutions.
Photo by João Marcelo Martins under Unsplash license.
Project News:
Note: If the dropdown does not run, try using the Chrome browser.
VI Iberian Meeting of Participatory Budgets
Participation in the intermediate seminar DEMOC 2023
Decidim Fest 2023 - Presentation of initial results
Presentation of the project at the DEMOC 2023 Research Webinar, June 7, 2023
Parte Hartuz 2023 Conference (UPV/EHU) - Participation Axis - April 28, 2023, in Bilbao
-
VI Iberian Meeting of Participatory Budgets
Presentation by Rosa Borge on the situation of participatory budgeting in Catalonia at the VI Iberian Meeting of Participatory Budgets in Vic. 12-14 June, 2024. Photo by Sergi -
Participation in the intermediate seminar DEMOC 2023
Last Thursday 15th February, the project team attended the seminar in the framework of the research "Evaluation of participatory budgets in Catalonia: satisfaction, problems and effects on political trust and legitimacy". -
Decidim Fest 2023 - Presentation of initial results
On October 20, 2023, as part of the Decidim Fest 2023, a presentation of the project was held and an initial sample of the results of the study carried out. -
Presentation of the project at the DEMOC 2023 Research Webinar, June 7, 2023
Rosa Borge, the lead researcher of the project, presented the study "Citizen Evaluation of Participatory Budgets in Catalonia: Satisfaction, Difficulties, and Effects on Political Trust and Legitimacy". The seminar, organized by the Directorate General of Good Governance, Innovation, and Democratic Quality, is part of the DEMOC call that funded this project. -
Parte Hartuz 2023 Conference (UPV/EHU) - Participation Axis - April 28, 2023, in Bilbao
Rosa Borge, the lead researcher of the project, presented the lecture "How Citizens Evaluate Participatory Budgets: Participation Success and Satisfaction Surveys. Application to the Catalan Case."